For Pair Of Small
Texas School Districts, There's No Place Like Domes
Structures Scheduled To Serve
Multitude Of Functions For Rural Communities
By Mark Rea
While many school districts in large Texas cities attempt
to keep pace with their swelling student populations by constructing
huge, multi-million-dollar high school campuses, smaller towns
with less money to spend must be more creative.
The rural communities of Italy and Avalon, located approximately
50 miles south of Dallas, were able to stretch their relatively
meager budgets into a pair of unusual gymnasium projects.
Each school district constructed a monolithic dome.
Simply put, a monolithic dome is a super-insulated, steel-reinforced
concrete structure originally designed for bulk storage facilities.
Neither district had to go very far to find a construction
manager for the projects; Monolithic Construction Management
is headquartered in Italy.
Each of the structures now resembles a miniature of the Houston
Astrodome, a Texas landmark since the 1960s. But the smaller
domes are much more than simple sports venues. According to
project manager Alden Porter, tight budget parameters and
energy efficiency set them apart from steel-framed structures.
"Once you get over 100 ft. in diameter, domes are more
economical than free-span steel buildings are," Porter
said. At the cost of about $85 per sq. ft., the $1.2 million
dome in Avalon came in about $50,000 under budget. The cost
per sq. ft. was the same for the $2 million multipurpose facility
in Italy.
"Not only do you save money in up front construction
costs," Porter added, "but perhaps the most important
aspect as far as a school district is concerned is that the
domes are so economical to operate as far as energy costs
are concerned. The dome has an effective R-value of 60, which
allows you to use approximately half of the air-conditioning
costs that you would have on a steel or metal building."
Safety is another important reason why more school districts
and small towns are entertaining the idea of building domes.
Each is built to meet or exceed the Federal Emergency Management
Agency guidelines for structures that can provide what the
agency calls near-absolute protection during severe storms.
According to FEMA, "Near-absolute protection means that,
based on our knowledge of tornadoes and hurricanes, the occupants
of a shelter built according to this guidance will be protected
from injury or death."
Avalon ISD superintendent David Del Bosque said, "We
looked at the cost of a traditional structure versus a dome
and were really impressed with what the long-term savings
would be in utilities, maintenance and those kinds of things.
"Also, I personally was concerned about safety for students
and the stability of the building in case of a storm. But
this is the safest structure anywhere here and we plan to
contact the Red Cross, get it certified and use it also as
a community storm shelter."
Unusual Beginnings
While most conventional structures begin with a foundation,
monolithic domes begin with construction of a ring beam.
"Because all of the weight and structure of the dome
comes down to the ground at the edges, we build a steel-reinforced
concrete ring beam based upon the structural engineering of
the dome itself," Porter said.
For example, the 148-ft. diameter dome in Italy was 36 in.
wide by about 2 ft. deep.
Once the ring beam is placed, a stemwall of 2-in.-thick reinforced
concrete is erected outside the ring beam and a specially
designed airform of the dome is attached. Stemwalls vary in
size according to the dome's size. For example, Italy's facility
features seating for 1,400 and was constructed on a 16-ft.
stemwall. The dome at Avalon is smaller with a dome diameter
of 124 ft.; it seats approximately 700 and was built on a
stemwall of 12 ft.
Once the airform is in place, it is inflated with fluctuations
in pressure to allow it to retain its shape. From grade to
the top of the stemwall, 3 in. of polyurethane foam insulation
is installed at a thickness of about a half-inch at a time.
Halfway through the process, crews place rebar hangers into
the walls. Each is a 6-in. piece of wire that sticks out through
the foam that will eventually hold reinforcing steel, which
is later placed in a horizontal/vertical checkerboard pattern
along the wall.
"Obviously, the size and end use of the dome may play
a factor," Porter said, "but normally we use No.
4 rebar tied 12 in. on center for the pattern."
After completion of the insulation installation, additional
rebar is installed at the top of the stemwall where it meets
the roof, which prevents the wall from pushing out sideways.
Once the checkerboard pattern of reinforcing steel is completed,
construction continues with shotcrete being sprayed on the
walls at 150 psi of pressure. The rate is approximately one-half
inch per application. Initial shotcrete mixtures include 3/8-in.
pea gravel and sand while final applications eliminate the
gravel to give the exterior a more even texture.
"Once the concrete covers the rebar, the dome is structurally
sound," Porter said. Additional smoothing techniques
of the shotcrete may be utilized and decorative patterns can
be added to the outside of the structure. The exterior of
the stemwall is typically finished with a coat of protective
elastomeric (acrylic) product.
"When it is finished, we typically have about 4 to 6
in. of concrete from top to bottom plus 3 in. of insulation
plus 2 in. of stemwall," Porter said. "That makes
for a wall thickness of about 9 in. at the top to about 11
in. at the bottom. You begin to see why these structures are
so safe and energy efficient."
The airform remains in place overhead to serve as a single-ply
roof membrane. The 3-in. layer of polyurethane foam acts as
insulation for the roof as it did for the stemwall and it
is topped by another 4 in. of sprayed shotcrete.
Slab Goes Last
Only when the dome structure is complete does underground
utility work begin. Plumbing and electrical lines are placed
before a 4-in. concrete slab is poured inside the dome.
"Because it is inside and protected from the weather,
you don't have the cracks in your slab that you might normally
see," Porter said. "The slab is able to cure without
being subjected to temperature fluctuations or sudden weather
changes. Then once the slab is complete, you can proceed with
the interior finish as you would any other building."
The domes are structurally strong enough to hold approximately
1 ton of material for every 6 ft. of vertical wall. "Hanging
such things as drop-in ceilings, catwalks or air conditioning
ducts is not an issue," Porter said. "You simply
go up there, attach them with wedge anchors and move on to
your next project."
The foundation of the building is also one of its strengths.
"You no longer have to worry about having structural
supports in the floor below, so there is no need for cross
beams or anything like that," Porter added.
In addition to its state-of-the-art gymnasium floor - a maple,
parquet floor installed by the same company that installed
the famous parquet floor in the old Boston Gardens - Italy's
facility contains locker rooms, a concession stand and ticket
booth.
Avalon also has four locker rooms in its facility and anticipates
using the dome long after basketball season has ended.
"In our opinion, there's no use having a beautiful building
like this and only using it for athletics," Del Bosque
said. "I'm hoping to have a summer recreation program
that will use the dome. You know how our summers are so hot.
"This dome is air-conditioned, so we can have an optional,
extended-year program that will run from 8 a.m. to 12:30 p.m.
We'll coordinate that with a federal free lunch program from
12:30 to 1 p.m. and then we'll open the gym from 1 to 4. So,
we'll have a full day of activities for the kids in the community.
I think it will be terrific."
| PROJECT TEAM |
|
CONSTRUCTION MANAGER: |
Monolithic Construction
Management, a division of Monolithic Constructors Inc.,
Italy |
|
OWNERS: |
Avalon Independent School
District, Italy Independent School District |
|
ARCHITECT: |
Rick Crandall & Associates,
Mesa, Ariz. |
|
MECHANICAL ENGINEER: |
Rodeo Air, Ennis |
|
ELECTRICAL: |
Estes Electric, Waxahachie
(Italy); Ennis Electric, Ennis (Avalon) |
|
PLUMBING: |
C.A. Wilson Co., Waxahachie
(Italy); Ashby Plumbing, Ben Wheeler (Avalon) |
|
CONCRETE FLATWORK: |
Robertson Concrete
Construction Co., Midlothian (Italy); Narrowgate Concrete
Construction, Grand Prairie (Avalon) |
|
CONCRETE SUPPLIER: |
Eureka Ready Mix Inc.,
Ennis |
|
REBAR SUPPLIER: |
The Lofland Co., Dallas |
|